A step by step tutorial on how to make a homemade pie crust that is buttery, flaky, and full of flavor. Perfect for all types of pies!
This post may contain affiliate links.
It’s official – pie making season is here. And I couldn’t be happier about it. To be honest, I am not a baker by nature. I enjoy baking and really enjoy eating things that are baked, but I’m more of a ‘throw everything in the pot and see how it comes out’ type of cook. Baking requires much more precision than that. It demands a specific list of ingredients that need to be measured and added in a certain order and finished within an allotted time frame. Pies are a little more forgiving than the average baked good. There is a certain amount of ‘throw everything together and see how it comes out’ with pies, which is probably why they are my favorite thing to bake. The key to any pie is the crust. It’s kind of the foundation. Once you master the crust, you can play around with all types of fillings. I think people are sometimes intimidated by the idea of making pie crust and they shouldn’t be. The important thing to remember is that pie crust does not need to be perfect. It’s job is functional – to hold its contents in place as it bakes and to taste good. It may take a little practice, but I promise that you can master pie crust. And once you do, you’ll never go back to store bought crust again.
Pie crust only contains a few ingredients. They include flour, butter, salt, water, and my secret ingredient – vinegar. I’m not entirely sure what the vinegar does, but I’m telling you there’s something to it. Start out with 3 cups of AP flour, 2 sticks of unsalted butter, and a pinch of salt. This is really important – the butter should be room temperature. The temperature of the butter is going to play a huge role in the success of your pie crust. Place the flour, butter, and salt in a sturdy bowl and grab a pastry cutter. Take the pastry cutter and start to ‘smash’ the butter into the flour. The butter should begin to break apart and incorporate into the flour. Do this for 3-5 minutes. Your wrist may get a little sore, but it’s totally worth it.
After a few minutes, the flour and butter mixture will become a bowl full of coarse crumbs. It should have the texture of cornmeal. All of the butter has been incorporated into the flour. The next step is the trickiest part (I think) of making pie crust. This includes adding the liquids and forming the whole thing into ball. Add 4-5 Tbsp. of cold water (very important that it’s cold) one at a time. Start with the first Tbsp. and begin to form the mixture into a ball with your hands. It will be crumbly at first. Continue to do this with the remaining 4-5 Tbsp. of cold water and 2 tsp. of vinegar (add one at a time and then continue to form a ball with your hands). The mixture should stick together in a ball after all the liquid has been added.
Split the ball of dough in two and flatten each one slightly. You should have two dough ‘patties’ at this point. Wrap each portion of dough with plastic wrap and place in the refrigerator for 15 minutes. This will cool the dough off slightly so that it doesn’t stick to your hands as you roll it out.
After the dough has chilled for 15 minutes, retrieve one or both (depending on how much you need) portions from the fridge and remove the plastic wrap. This is the fun (and messy) part. Place the dough on a clean and even surface. Coat the surface, the dough, and a rolling pin with flour. It is important that there is flour under the dough so that it doesn’t stick to the surface. Begin to roll the dough out with a rolling pin. Start with short, light stokes and as the dough stretches you can press down harder to flatten it. Flip the dough over once or twice to make sure it doesn’t stick and sprinkle with more flour if needed.
The sides may crack a little bit and you might get little tears in the crust. That’s OK – just pinch any cracks or tears together with your fingers. The most important thing is that it does not stick to the surface because it may rip apart as you remove it and place it in the pie pan. If the dough rips apart for any reason, you can re-form it into a ball and try again.
Place a pie pan or baking sheet near the dough. You don’t want to carry pie dough across the kitchen – this would likely cause it to break. Carefully slide the dough across the pan and press down so that it lines the surface. Again, the sides may crack or tear a little bit and that’s OK. The goal is not perfection.
You can trim the edges from the pie crust to fit the pan if desired. I like to sprinkle those pie crust scraps with cinnamon and sugar and bake them for a little ‘pre-pie’ treat. You can crimp the edges or press them down with a fork for that classic pie look. This recipe makes two 9-inch pie crusts. You can roll out one or both of them depending on the type of pie you are baking. If you become a pie crust master (and have a lot of patience) you can use the crust decoratively to make a lattice top or pie crust cutouts. I’m just in it for the most important part – eating.
- 3 cups AP flour + 2 Tbsp. for sprinkling
- 2 sticks unsalted butter
- Pinch salt
- 4-5 Tbsp cold water
- 2 tsp vinegar
- Bring butter to room temperature.
- Place flour, butter, and salt in a sturdy bowl. Begin to smash and cut the butter into the flour with a pastry cutter. Do this for 3-5 minutes until all of the butter has incorporated into the flour and the texture resembles cornmeal.
- Add 4-5 Tbsp. of cold water (one at a time) and 2 tsp. vinegar to the flour/butter mixture. After each addition of liquid, form the mixture into a ball. It will be crumbly at first, but should stick together after all liquid has been added.
- Split the ball of pie dough into two portions and flatten each of them slightly to form two dough patties.
- Wrap each portion of dough with plastic wrap and refrigerate for 15 minutes.
- Retrieve dough from fridge and remove plastic wrap.
- Place dough on a clean and even surface and sprinkle surface, pie dough, and rolling pin with flour.
- Begin to roll out dough lightly. As it flattens, press down harder with rolling pin. Check to make sure bottom is not sticking to surface.
- Once desired thickness is reached, carefully remove the pie crust and place onto pie pan or baking sheet.
- Remove excess dough and crimp edges if desired.
Carefully mend any tears or cracks in pie crust with fingers while rolling it out.